Elon Says He Was 'Entirely Focused' on Tesla As Court Debates His $56 Billion Compensation PackageElon Musk avoided a trial over his purchase of Twitter, but the billionaire was back at the Court of Chancery on Wednesday.

ByGabrielle BienaszOriginally published

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Justin Sullivan I Getty Images
Elon Musk at a Tesla event in 2015.

A lot of business — and the attendant court cases — flow through Delaware, and it looks like the CEO of Tesla and "Chief Twit" at Twitter Elon Musk spent some time there Wednesday.

The world's richest manacquired Twitterin late October after getting sued by the company in Delaware's Chancery Court to make him go through with the deal. Now, the same court — and the same judge as the Twitter case, Kathaleen St. J. McCormick — is hearing a different case related to Musk.

Musk testified on Wednesday related to issues raised about his executive compensation, particularly as to whether he was devoted enough on Tesla to receive that large of an amount of money.

"I was entirely focused" on running Tesla, he said,per the Associated Press.

The lawsuit that started the court case was filed by Tesla shareholder Richard Tornetta, whoclaimsthat Musk's board-approved compensation package from 2018 was excessive and breached the board's duties to shareholders. Further, the suit claims Musk has too much on his plate to pull a compensation package that can go up to a value of over $50 billion, per TechCrunch.

The legal documents call it "the largest compensation grant in human history," the outlet noted.

Tesla and Twitter are both incorporatedin Delaware, as are most very large businesses, due to the state's tax benefits. This is why both cases will be in the state's Chancery Court. It has "unique competence," in the nitty-gritty of business law.

The trial will last about a week, and Judge McCormick will probably issue a ruling within a few months,according to the New York Times.

What is the Tesla lawsuit about?

Musk's compensation (stock options,salaries, and bonuses) as CEO of Tesla (going back to 2009) was pegged to performance,as noted in the 2019 pre-trial opinionfrom Joseph R. Slights III, who was formerly vice chancellor of the Court of Chancery. (McCormicktook overthe case from Slights.)

After Tesla met the goals outlined in past compensation packages, the board created a new one for Musk and voted to approve it in January 2018.

The new package set a series of 12 performance goals, and corresponding groups of stocks, related to Tesla's ability to increase its market capitalization, as well as revenue and earnings. Upon hitting those goals "corresponding to each tranche of the Award, options held by Musk representing 1% of Tesla's current total outstanding shares will vest," Slights wrote.

This means that Musk would earn the equivalent of 1% of the company's total outstanding shares. If he met all of those goals, Slights added, the maximum value of the total stock grant is $55.8 billion. The company has met 11 out of 12 so far, per TechCrunch.

Tornetta sued in 2019 saying that the package was too large and did notmotivateMusk to focus on Tesla versus his other ventures. Musk, of course, is a busy man. He is the listed CEO of Tesla and SpaceX and now Twitter, at least in the interim.

Related:Elon Musk's Twitter Mass Layoffs Have Begun: 'Has The Red Wedding Started?

Musk's legal team has said that a one-of-a-kind, high-powered CEO deserves a high-impact compensation package.

"The plan designed and approved by the board was not a typical pay package intended to compensate the ordinary executive for overseeing the day-to-day operations of a mature company," a Musk attorney, Evan Chesler, wrote in a filing,per Bloomberg Law."That is because Musk is not the typical CEO."

On that topic: In court, attorney for the plantiffs, Greg Varallo, asked Musk about his title at Tesla, "Technoking."

"I think comedy is legal," Musk answered the attorney. Varallo also asked questions about how he manages to run his various companies, from Twitter to SpaceX.

The multi-billionaire CEO told Varallo being the leaders of any of these companies was not really the plan and that he likes to be more of an engineer, the AP reported.

Musk said that he had at one point debated leaving Tesla. Board member later Antonio Gracias later Wednesday said that it was too hard to find a replacement, per the Times.

"We needed him all the way in, all the time," Gracias said.

The lawsuit claimed that because Musk is friends with board members including Ira Ehrenpreis and James Murdoch, he generally exerts too much influence over it — despite recusing himself and his brother Kimbal from the compensation discussion — and the decision was not fair,accordingto TechCrunch.

When he testified Wednesday, Musk claimed that the vacations he's been on with some of the board members were not super intimate.

"For me, it was email with a view," he told the court. Gracias affirmed in his testimony that he has vacationed with Musk.

The question of whether or not there was a conflict of interest is part of why the Slights initially denied Musk'sattempt to dismiss the suit. Typically, the court would leave executive compensation up to a company, and "this court's earnest deference to board determinations relating to executive compensation does not jibe with our reflexive suspicion when a board transacts with a controlling stockholder," Slights wrote in the 2019 opinion.

是否没有麝香操作控制stakeholder (Musk owns the largest stake in Tesla but not the majority, leaving it up for debate) will likely come up again as McCormick hears the case, one expert told Bloomberg Law.

Generally speaking, "this has the potential to be a very important case from an executive compensation standpoint," business law professor at the University of Pennsylvania Jill Fisch told the outlet.

“它不会得到Musk-Twitter案件的重视got from the general public, but it's still important," she said.

Wavy Line
Gabrielle Bienasz is a staff writer at Entrepreneur. She previously worked at Insider and Inc. Magazine.

Editor's Pick

Related Topics

Social Media

How This 18-Year-Old TikTok Star Built a Business With 5 Million Followers

TikToker Ryan Shakes shares how he built a devoted and engaged following.

Science & Technology

The Rising Threat of Generative AI in Social Engineering Cyber Attacks — What You Need to Know

The rise of generative AI is revolutionizing social engineering cyber attacks, making them more sophisticated and harder to detect. As these threats escalate, individuals and organizations must stay informed, exercise caution and employ robust cybersecurity measures to counteract this new wave of AI-driven cybercrime.

Growing a Business

5 Essential Steps to Drive a Culture of Continuous Improvement

Discover how to unlock your organization's potential for growth and innovation by fostering a culture of continuous improvement, leading to increased productivity, employee engagement, and long-term success.

Starting a Business

10 Common Obstacles to Avoid When Starting a Business

Starting a new business can be an exciting and rewarding venture, but it also comes with its fair share of challenges. Here are some common obstacles to avoid when starting a new business.

Business Ideas

The Top 10 Home Business Ideas for 2023

Can't figure out which enterprise you should launch in 2023? Check out 10 stellar home business ideas to get inspiration.