Don't Uberize, Strategize! 3 Steps to a Better Business Model.Want to shake up your industry? Avoid the pitfalls of the the 1-size-fits-all 'Uber for X' approach.

ByZach Ferres

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Shutterstock

Another month, another Uber-like startup that fails to please. This time, Uber-for-anything delivery startup Postmates isembroiled in controversyfor breaking its promise to make instant-anything affordable.

Related:在其狗万官方5年5创业Uber教训Anniversary

Under the right circumstances, Uber's model makes sense: Let's say you've had a few too many whiskey shots, so you need a ride home. But these days, a few too many entrepreneurs are running their businessesoff the roadby mindlessly applying this same "Uber for X" template to their own businesses [sert any industry here]. And that's proved to be a bad decision in many cases.

To understand why, consider the history of Uber's business model: The company's success may have popularized the sharing economy, but the startup-turned-superpower certainly didn't invent it: Sharing idle resources for unmet demand has been the battle cry of Enterprise Rent-A-Car since 1957. Fleet vehicles have been tracked by GPS for more than 20 years. And Pizza Hut wouldn't exist if it weren't for the good ol' on-demand model we call pizza delivery.

So, what, exactly is "revolutionary" about Uber's marketplace business model? Well, eBay has been connecting supply and demand and taking a cutsince 1996.

And the use of independent contractors? That idea is much, much older than Uber CEO Travis Kalanick. Avon has been doing itsince 1886.

None of Uber's characteristics or practices, considered individually, is, in fact, new. Uber's business model has succeeded, frankly, because it's blended together old ideas in order to solve people's frustrations with an even older problem: multiple cities' crappy taxi systems.

Uberizing gone bad

In all, I'm sorry to tell you that not only is Uber's model not magic in and of itself: It's certainlynotmagic for every business.

"Uber for X" clone Shuddle, for example, failed because that kid-chauffeuring service was essentially anUber add-on, not a stand-alone business. ZIRX went bust because it had topay on-demandvalets to wait for text alerts. Homejoylearned the hard waythat customers would rather schedule their cleaning services themselves.

Likewise, Cherry failed because itincorrectly assumedvehicles needed bathing as often as humans do.

All of these fails are not to say that on-demand is always a bad strategy. The key is to understand when, how and why customers want a service. Then, pick your tools accordingly.

Cherry may have been a sexy, Uberesque business, but it discovered that the model wasn't right for car washes. Alternatively, subscription-basedMister Car Washgave customers unlimited washes at brick-and-mortar locations, a formula that got it scooped up fornearly half a billion dollars.

ZipSit, a startup we built at Coplex, found a winning recipe by taking a few tools from Uber's caddy but tailoring them for the baby-sitting business. We realized that nobody wants to call a random stranger as a last-minute baby sitter, so we used technology and close-knit social circles to tailor an on-demand service for watching kiddos.

Related:10 On-Demand Services to Watch 2016

Disrupt without going belly-up

Chomping at the bit to change your industry? Here are three strategies to make the trip pleasant and prosperous:

1. Find out where it hurts.

The biggest flaw with the "Uber for X" concept is its one-size-fits-all approach. It drives entrepreneurs to build businesses backward, starting with the solution before diagnosing the needs and nuances of the individual industry involved. In the car wash industry, for instance, Cherry offered pricey on-location services -- an unattractive option compared with Mister Car Wash's unlimited DIY model.

So, get outof your headand into the real world. Observe customers' sticking points, and let your findings fuel your solution.

2. Go lean to test the waters.

A startup is nothing more than a set of untested assumptions. Maybe you've seen that some people hate waiting in line for coffee, but is it fair to assume they would pay for coffee delivery?

Before phoning even one investor, get out there and test, test, test. Uber, for instance,relied on SMSbefore it shipped an app. Talk to real customers -- not your friends -- and ask for a monetary commitment to your solution. No takers? Back to the drawing board.

If you find you're on the right track, iterate on your experiments. At ZipSit, we confirmed that parents were willing to schedule a baby sitter via an app before we started writing thousands of lines of code. Only then did we build and grow.

To this day, we use theminimum viable productapproach to validate our beliefs. Everyone should do this before building thenext Uber, staking a big business bet.

3. Dump the price-dumping strategy.

Creating a business model built on price-dumping for market penetration is an incredibly risky idea. To keep investors happy, entrepreneurs should prepare for profitability, "so that it occurs much sooner than may have been accepted historically," according to consulting firmKPMG.

Planning for the stars to align is a plan for failure, as yet another company, Instacart, found out. The grocery startup kept prices artificially low,banking on future revenuefrom supermarkets. When that didn't happen, Instacart was forced to raise prices and slash wages.

Related:4 Fatal Sharing Economy Mistakes

In the end, Uber hit on the right blend of business tools to disrupt the transportation industry -- high-fives all around. But the model is far from plug-and-play, so before you go forth making Uber for ice cream cones, remember: Most of us don't like melted ice cream.

Wavy Line
Zach Ferres

Entrepreneur Leadership Network Writer

Advisor, Board Member & Investor

Zach Ferres is a serial entrepreneur, speaker and technology executive passionate about developing entrepreneurial communities around the world. He built and sold his first tech company at 24 and was the CEO of Coplex for eight years, where he supported the creation of over 200 startup companies.

Editor's Pick

Related Topics

Money & Finance

Want to Become a Millionaire? Follow Warren Buffett's 4 Rules.

企业家是不能过度指狗万官方望太多a company exit for their eventual 'win.' Do this instead.

Business Solutions

Learn to Program an AI Chatbot for Your Business in This $30 Course

Get back-to-school savings on this AI coding course.

Growing a Business

We're Now Finding Out The Damaging Results of The Mandated Return to Office — And It's Worse Than We Thought.

Companies knew the mandated return to the office would cause some attrition, however, they were not prepared for the serious problems that would present.

Business News

Netflix is Hiring an AI-Focused Role—and the Starting Salary is up to $900,000

The streaming giant is looking for a leader in its machine learning department.

Data & Recovery

Get 1TB of Cloud Storage for Life for $119.97 With This Back-to-School Sale

This 1TB Cloud Storage Solution Is Only $119.97 for Back to School

Business Ideas

55 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2023

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2023.