Why the Accenture Gender-Parity Target Is Insane -- and Bad for WomenHiring minorities just for the sake of diversity doesn't help anyone.

ByCarol Roth

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Accenture | Instagram

Accenture, one of the world's best-known consulting firms for major enterprises,announcedthat they have set a target to have 50 percent of its workforce be comprised of women within the next eight years.

Let me repeat this: They have set a workforce target not based on experience, qualifications, potential or any work-related factors. They have set a target for their workforce based on what body parts you have (or which you identify with having, depending on definitions).

This precedent is not only insane, but as a woman, I find it offensive and, ultimately, bad for women and business.

Businesses should be interviewing and hiring the best possible candidates they can find for their business -- period. Doing anything else is a disservice to the company's culture, shareholders and clients.

Related:22 Qualities That Make a Great Leader

Diversity is important because it ensures that a variety of perspectives, experiences, networks and thought processes are included in the company's toolkit. This ostensibly gives companies a richer pool of information to draw from and more thoughtful outcomes for their customers.

Diversity for the sake of diversity, though, doesn't help anything. If people who are supposedly representing some supposed group -- women, LGBTQ, etc. -- aren't the best people for the job, they start being perceived as a token. That hurts future opportunities for people who are viewed as part of that group, rather than an individual, and causes schisms in company culture.

Additionally, diversity is not just who you are based on genetics, but the different experiences you have assembled over time based on where you grew up, income and a whole host of other factors.

As I havewritten aboutextensively, including in this space, genetics is not something you can control the way you can control your attitude, work ethic and more. That's why it shouldn't be a factor in getting (or not getting) a job.

Related:11 Habits of Truly Happy People

Moreover, women face a lot of factors that shape how they approach work. For some, their interests lie in certain industries, which mean that some industries will have more women and some will have less. Other women have a strong preference to leave the workforce to run a household and care for children. If this decision fits the goals and objectives of those women, then there will be less of them in the workforce.

Is there a problem with women being underrepresented in certain industries and at the higher levels of companies? Absolutely.

Does arbitrary representation targeting help? Absolutely not.

If companies want to help women (or anyone else whose perspective and experience they feel is underrepresented) succeed, make sure that qualified, experienced women and those with the capacity to learn are considered as part of the interview process. Once these women are hired, mentor them, network with them and recommend them for appropriate positions that may come up.

Related:5习惯帮助他们致富的富人

Companies can also broaden the types of experience required for people in certain positions. For example, a lot of women don't make boards of directors because they are looking for C-level executives. Broadening those qualifications to others that can also make strong directors can yield more candidate diversity.

But, for god's sake, don't start throwing out targets based on what someone is versus who someone is. It's not good for your business and while the intentions may be noble, it's not good for those who receive a job that someone else is better qualified for, either.

Carol Roth

Entrepreneur, TV host and small business expert

Carol Rothis the creator of theFuture File™ legacy planning system, a “recovering” investment banker, business advisor, entrepreneur and best-selling author. She is also areality TV show judge、媒体撰稿人和主机的微软Office Small Business Academy. A small business expert, Roth has worked with companies of all sizes on everything from strategy to content creation and marketing to raising capital. She’s been a public company director and invests in mid-stage companies, as well.

Editor's Pick

Related Topics

Business News

'Typically Gone Within a Few Hours': This $1,900 Costco Product Is Flying Off Shelves

Costco only offers the exclusive product online to members.

Business News

Katy Perry Is Fighting the Founder of 1-800-Flowers for a $15 Million California Mansion He Doesn't Want to Sell Her

The eight-bedroom, 11-bathroom estate sits on nearly nine acres in the Santa Ynez foothills in Montecito.

Business News

'No Question, We Probably Went Too Far': Delta Airlines CEO Backtracks on Sweeping Changes to SkyMiles Accounts, Sky Club Access

The unpopular changes set to roll out in 2025 were announced earlier this month.

Employee Experience & Recruiting

3 Truths About Unlimited PTO — Why Employees Are Worse Off With Endless Vacation Days

Three truths that might make you reconsider the appeal of unlimited PTO.

Growing a Business

Want to Sound Smarter? This Stanford Professor's Simple 3-Point Technique Will Help

With a little structure, you can impress audiences with your ad-libbing all day.

Business News

The Justice Department Is Suing eBay, Alleging Unlawful Sales of Over 371,000 Products

The lawsuit alleges that eBay violated several environmental laws.